Open Letter #BillofRights: “Prime responsibility for accident and ill health prevention rests with management”: An Open Letter to Caroline Russell, Chair, London

Live from London Bus Forums News

Live London Bus Forums News

Checking for live updates…

The latest live story will appear here when available.

By blogpost

Caroline Russell, Chair
London Assembly Transport Committee
City Hall
Kamal Chunchie Way
London E16 1ZE
cc: London Assembly Transport Committee Members; London Bus Forums; Michael Liebreich; Lorraine Robertson


9 November 2026​

RE: “Prime responsibility for accident and ill health prevention rests with management”

Thank you for your prompt response (below) to London Bus Driver Lorraine Robertson's 26 October Open Letter "Bus Driver Bill of Rights: Please Investigate TfL's Unsafe Bus Contracting Model".

Since Recommendation 1 of the 2017 "
Driven to Distraction" Bus Safety Investigation was—​


"TfL should set safety targets for bus operators. We suggest the best way to do this is to integrate safety targets in the QIC [Quality Incentive Contract]s performance target structure as soon as possible"​


—I am pleased that the Transport Committee will be following up on this landmark investigation's scope in the new year.

It is precisely with Recommendation 1 in mind that I understand Lorraine Robertson made this statement in her letter:
​


"Because the safety regulation framework for buses in the United Kingdom does not provide a robust, detailed safety code specifically for public bus operations, TfL’s Framework Bus Services Agreement itself must serve as the safety regulator. Even though TfL has served as the sole contractor of public bus services in London since it was created in 2000, it has manifestly refused to fill the gap between the non-existent national bus safety framework and high public expectations that buses must be reliable. As both the 2017 and 2024 London Assembly Transport Committee Bus Safety Investigations made crystal clear, instead of putting safety first, TfL and the Mayor of London have wittingly presided over a public bus operation that risks lives and livelihoods by agreeing contracts with Bus Operators containing financial incentives to ensure timely bus performance. Accordingly, the systemic problems associated with these defective contract performance metrics go unmeasured, so safety is effectively unregulated. This conclusion has been well evidenced by decades of Drivers reporting the systemic safety problems identified by the Bill of Rights."​


Since the public record shows that Quality Incentive Contracts were introduced "from summer 2001" about six months after [now Lord] Peter Hendy arrived from First Group to serve as TfL's Managing Director for Surface Transport, I think it is important that the Committee consider the exchange of letters between the Managing Director of London Bus Forums, Dylan Carroll (cf. 26 July "London bus driver working conditions and ministerial awareness") and the 20 October response from Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State Department for Transport, Simon Lightwood MP (also below).

As you will note, the 26 July letter simply apprises the Minister of the horrific working conditions of London Bus Drivers revealed by ITV's ongoing investigation and requests that Mr. Lightwood inquire of his Ministerial colleagues, Lord Peter Hendy and Heidi Alexander, "to confirm whether the concerns and working conditions described in these reports were known to them during their respective tenures and, if so, what action was taken at the time"

As you know, Lord Hendy served as TfL’s Managing Director of Surface Transport from 2001 to 2006 and as Commissioner of Transport for London from 2006 to 2015 and Heidi Alexander served as Deputy Mayor for Transport and Deputy Chair of Transport for London from 2018 to 2021.

The Minister's conclusion—
​


"Transport in London is devolved and is the responsibility of the Mayor of London and Transport for London. The Government has regular discussion with TfL on a range of issues, however the management of working conditions for their bus drivers is a matter solely for them and their contractors."​



—reaffirms that both (a) the 2017 Driven to Distraction Investigation's Recommendation 1 and (b) Lorraine Robertson's thoughtful observation that "TfL’s Framework Bus Services Agreement itself must serve as the safety regulator", are indeed reasonable starting points for the Committee's investigation. The Minster's 10 October letter also confirms that the Mayor's refusal to instruct TfL to set (a) a maximum working temperature for bus cabs and (b) establish an independent bus crash investigation unit, are, at best, misguided. The government clearly thinks these safe actions are entirely within the Mayor's writ.

On that note, I also recommend that you listen to the speech given by former TfL Board Director (2012-18) and Board Safety Panel Chair (2016-18) Michael Liebreich at last week's Bus Driver Bill of Rights Rally and March at TfL Headquarters, that cogently explains the "Blame Culture" which underpins TfL's design, management and enforcement of the Framework Bus Contract that the Bill of Rights campaign reasonably seeks to amend to guarantee that London Bus Drivers aren't forced to continue working in the unsafe conditions they have endured for decades.

Finally, since today marks the 10th Anniversary of the Sandilands Disaster, I think it's worthwhile to heed the 27 July 2023 Sentencing Remarks of Justice Fraser, in particular, his references to the published Health and Safety Guidance which places the accountability for unsafe systems which make human error inevitable squarely on the shoulders of management—
​


“The Health and Safety Executive (“the HSE”) issued a guidance document entitled “Reducing error and influencing behaviour” which is called HSG48, and its 2nd edition was published in 1999.

It states:

“Human failure and accidents

Over the last 20 years we have learnt much more about the origins of human failure. We can now challenge the commonly held belief that incidents and accidents are the result of a ‘human error’ by a worker in the ‘front line’. Attributing incidents to ‘human error’ has often been seen as a sufficient explanation in itself and something which is beyond the control of managers. This view is no longer acceptable to society as a whole. Organisations must recognise that they need to consider human factors as a distinct element which must be recognised, assessed and managed effectively in order to control risks.”

Another HSE guidance document called HSG65 (2nd edition published in 1997) states: “Prime responsibility for accident and ill health prevention rests with management”


Accidents, ill health and incidents are seldom random events. They generally arise from failures of control and involve multiple contributory elements. The immediate cause may be a human or technical failure, but they usually arise from organisational failings which are the responsibility of management.”
​


With (a) Justice Fraser's 2023 Sentencing Remarks in mind (b) the horrific revelations coming from both ITV's and MyLondon's investigations, and (c) heeding Mr. Lightwood's clear guidance that "the management of working conditions for their bus drivers is a matter solely for them [TfL] and their contractors", the (d) recent HSE conviction of TfL for failing to protect pedestrians at Walthamstow Bus Station from 1 January 2004 and 15 December 2023, suggests that the Transport Committee is also within its rights to invite Lord Hendy and Heidi Alexander for questioning as part of its impending Bus Safety investigation.

I reckon the families of the (a) (at least) 123 people who've died in preventable bus safety incidents (b) (at least) 76 Bus Drivers who died from Covid-19 and (c) 7 passengers who died in the Sandilands crash—lives all lost while Sadiq Khan has served as TfL Chair and London's "Vision Zero" Mayor—might applaud the Committee if it were to subject the Ministers to much-needed public scrutiny about whether or not they ever felt that "the prime responsibility for accident and ill health prevention" rested with them while they occupied key senior transport leadership positions at City Hall and TfL.

Yours sincerely,

​

Tom Kearney

#LondonBusWatch​
E: [email protected]
Twitter: @comadad
Bluesky: @comadad.bsky.social
Blog: www.saferoxfordstreet.blogspot.co.uk
Bus Services [No. 2] Bill Evidence Submission [July 2025]: https://bills.parliament.uk/publications/61937/documents/6837
London Assembly Transport Committee Investigation [April 2024]: https://www.london.gov.uk/about-us/...rom Tom Kearney received 15 December 2023.pdf
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@BetterBuses - and https://www.youtube.com/@tomkearney955

​
2018 Winner, Community Hero Award — The Johns Hopkins University Alumni Association
2016 Winner, Transport – Sheila McKechnie Foundation SMK Campaigners Award
​

ATTACHMENT 1

From: @london.gov.uk

Subject: FW: Open Letter from Lorraine Robertson: Bus Driver Bill of Rights: Please Investigate TfL's Unsafe Bus Contracting Model

Date: 29 October 2026 at 16:23:08 GMT

To: Tom Kearney <[email protected]>, Lorraine Bus Driver <. @hotmail.com>



Dear Tom,

Thank you for your email.

As the Principal Committee Manager of the London Assembly Transport Committee, I am writing on behalf of the Chair, Caroline Russell.

The Committee’s work programme includes two meetings in January and February 2027 as a follow up the Committee’s work ‘Driven to Distraction – tackling safety on London’s buses’ from 2017. The meetings are still being scoped, and the Committee will take into consideration the issues raised as we prepare for the meetings. However, we will not be able to cover all the items in the time we have available.

Many thanks,

.



.

Principal Committee Manager, Committee Services

LONDONASSEMBLY

City Hall, Kamal Chunchie Way, London E16 1ZE

ATTACHMENT 2

​
​










Source: https://saferoxfordstreet.blogspot.com/2026/11/billofrights-prime-responsibility-for.html
Auto-imported from Tom Kearney’s blog.
 
Advertisement
Back
Top