Bus Safety Cannot Stop at the Driver — We Have to Look at the System Around Them

Live from London Bus Forums News

Live London Bus Forums News

Checking for live updates…

The latest live story will appear here when available.

Status
Not open for further replies.

​

Why working conditions, timetables, fatigue, welfare and workforce evidence have to be part of the national bus-safety conversation​


A note before I begin: I write this in a personal capacity as a serving bus driver and trade union representative with around 20 years' experience in the industry.

This article discusses national bus policy, safety and regulation. It does not comment on the safety performance of my employer or any individual bus operator, and no confidential employer information has been used.



A short video sent to me this week by bus-safety campaigner Tom Kearney stopped me in my tracks.

It was an extract from a speech given by Michael Liebreich, a former Transport for London Board Director and former Safety Panel Chair, at the Bus Drivers' Bill of Rights rally outside TfL headquarters on 5 November 2026.

Whatever view people may take of some of the wider claims made during that speech, one part deserves serious consideration far beyond London.

Liebreich points directly towards bus-driver working conditions and argues that decision-makers need to get to the underlying problem and talk to the drivers themselves.

That is the important point.

And it is not a London-only point.

It is a national one.

For years we have discussed bus collisions, punctuality failures, reliability, driver behaviour, road safety, passenger safety and operator performance as though they can all be neatly separated.

They cannot.

When something goes wrong, of course the actions of the person driving the vehicle may need to be examined.

But the investigation should not stop there.

We also need to ask:

What system was that driver working within?

The driver is the final link in a much bigger chain​


A professional bus driver does not design the timetable.

The driver does not decide the scheduled running time.

The driver does not decide how much recovery is provided at the terminus.

The driver does not determine staffing establishment, vehicle allocation, engineering policy, contract incentives, road layouts, traffic-signal priorities or the location of welfare facilities.

The driver does not control congestion, roadworks or how long passengers need to board safely.

Yet when the bus is late, when something goes wrong or when an incident occurs, attention can very quickly narrow onto the individual sitting behind the steering wheel.

That is sometimes necessary.

But it is not enough.

A serious safety system should also ask:

  • Was the timetable realistically achievable?
  • Had the same journey been routinely running late?
  • Was recovery time repeatedly being lost?
  • How long had the driver been on duty?
  • Had rest and welfare breaks actually been available in practice?
  • Was overtime or rest-day working contributing to cumulative fatigue?
  • Was there pressure to recover lost time?
  • Was the driver being contacted or distracted while the vehicle was moving?
  • Was the vehicle fit for the conditions?
  • Was the cab excessively hot?
  • Were toilet and rest facilities available?
  • Had drivers previously reported the same problem?
  • If they had, what happened to those reports?
  • Were there recurring problems at the same junction, stop or section of route?
  • Did the commercial or performance system create incentives which unintentionally increased pressure?

Those are systems questions.

And systems questions matter because serious incidents rarely emerge from one factor in isolation.

This argument is already national​


The idea that bus-driver working conditions belong within the safety framework did not suddenly appear in London in 2026.

The National Bus Drivers' Bill of Rights was adopted at the 76th RMT National Industrial Organising Conference of Busworkers in Salisbury in April 2019 and subsequently carried by the RMT Annual General Meeting.

It established ten straightforward principles:

  1. The right to a safe work schedule without forced overtime or loss of pay.
  2. The right to a decent and proper rest break in the working day.
  3. The right to drive a safe and well-maintained vehicle.
  4. The right to clean, serviced toilet and rest facilities on bus routes.
  5. The right to report safety concerns without fear of retribution.
  6. The right not to be pressured back to work when medically unfit.
  7. The right to relevant and timely safety training.
  8. The right to drive without inappropriate distraction from controller communications.
  9. The right to clear written company rules.
  10. The right to dignity and respect.

In April 2025 my own Nottinghamshire & Derbyshire Bus Branch brought the issue back to the National Bus Workers Conference in Exeter, calling for renewed national campaigning and accountability for what had been done since 2019.

The same Conference separately supported the London Bus Drivers' Bill of Rights campaign.

Those are related campaigns.

But they should not be confused.

London can provide useful evidence and precedent.

The principle is national.

Every professional bus driver should be able to operate within conditions that support safe driving.

Punctuality and safety cannot be separated​


This has become particularly important because the Senior Traffic Commissioner is currently reviewing the national regulatory guidance covering local bus service performance.

The consultation asks whether the long-established expectation that 95% of timetabled services operate within the permitted punctuality window remains appropriate.

My answer was yes.

Passengers deserve reliable services.

Passengers are entitled to expect that a published timetable means something.

But I made an equally important point:

How that punctuality is achieved matters.

A service should not be regarded as successfully managed if its punctuality depends upon drivers routinely losing recovery time, delaying welfare breaks, working under constant time pressure or trying to achieve running times which the operational evidence shows are unrealistic.

That is not an argument for lowering performance standards.

It is an argument for designing services capable of meeting them safely.

Modern AVL and BODS information gives operators and authorities far more evidence than they once had.

If hundreds of journeys demonstrate that a particular section routinely needs 14 minutes at 08:00 but the timetable repeatedly allows ten, the problem is no longer unknowable.

The answer cannot simply be to expect the driver to somehow find four minutes.

The timetable should be examined.

Fatigue is part of the safety system​


The same applies to fatigue.

My branch and the wider RMT bus sector have repeatedly raised concerns about local bus driving-hours rules, rest periods and cumulative fatigue.

In 2024, the Bus Workers Conference backed a resolution seeking restoration of the requirement for a break after 5.5 hours on duty, rather than only after 5.5 hours of driving. The issue subsequently progressed through the union's national structures.

In 2025 our Conference work also sought stronger driving-hours protection through the Bus Services legislation.

These issues are sometimes described as purely industrial demands.

I disagree with that distinction.

A fatigued professional driver is a safety issue.

A driver whose scheduled recovery repeatedly disappears because the timetable is unrealistic is a safety issue.

A driver undertaking long duties, additional work and inadequate recovery is not simply experiencing an employment problem.

The potential consequences travel with the vehicle.

That is why fatigue needs to be considered alongside punctuality and performance rather than sitting in a completely separate policy box.

Heat showed how fragmented the system can be​


The same lesson became painfully clear during the extreme heat of 2026.

My branch submitted an emergency resolution to the RMT AGM on bus-driver heat safety, cab temperatures and national standards.

It was carried unanimously.

The resolution did not simply ask employers to give drivers more water.

It identified a much wider regulatory gap.

Bus-driver heat safety can sit somewhere between:

  • the operator;
  • HSE;
  • DVSA;
  • the Department for Transport;
  • Traffic Commissioners;
  • Local Transport Authorities;
  • Combined Authorities;
  • vehicle manufacturers; and
  • contract or franchising bodies.

Everyone has part of the picture.

But who owns the whole risk?

Our resolution called for national action on matters including:

  • legally enforceable maximum working temperatures;
  • effective cab cooling and ventilation;
  • UV and solar protection;
  • heat-related vehicle defect standards;
  • retrofitting older vehicles where reasonably practicable;
  • heatwave operating procedures;
  • drinking water;
  • toilet access;
  • cool rest areas;
  • additional welfare breaks;
  • relief arrangements;
  • recovery time;
  • protection for drivers raising genuine safety concerns;
  • national evidence gathering;
  • international best practice; and
  • climate-resilient procurement and franchising standards.

Most importantly, it recognised that heat interacts with other risks.

A driver who has slept badly through several hot nights, is working a long duty, has limited recovery, is operating under timetable pressure and is then placed in an excessively hot cab is not experiencing five completely independent problems.

They combine.

That is what systems safety means.

Toilet facilities are not a minor welfare issue either​


The same is true of toilet access.

It can sound almost trivial when placed alongside collision prevention.

It is not.

If a driver does not know when they will next have access to a toilet, that affects hydration.

Hydration becomes particularly important in extreme heat.

Lack of toilet access can create anxiety and physical discomfort.

A driver arriving late may face the choice between using the toilet and departing even later.

That is precisely why the National Bus Drivers' Bill of Rights included clean and serviced toilet and rest facilities, and why the bus sector has continued campaigning on toilet dignity.

A well-designed service considers the human being expected to operate it.

Drivers also need a safe way to report problems​


Another recurring theme in my work has been protected safety reporting.

If drivers repeatedly experience the same dangerous junction, timetable problem, defective cab environment, near miss or welfare failure, the organisation should want to know.

But a reporting system only works if the person reporting genuinely believes it is safe to use.

That is why my branch advanced proposals at the 2025 National Bus Workers Conference for an independent confidential safety-reporting mechanism.

Other safety-critical transport sectors understand the importance of learning from frontline staff.

The bus industry should do the same.

A mature organisation does not ask:

“Who can we blame for raising this?”

It asks:

“What are they telling us that could prevent something worse?”

We also need better national safety data​


This connects directly with another campaign I have pursued for years.

In 2019 I used Freedom of Information requests to examine how Local Transport Authorities outside London collected and published bus-safety information.

The results demonstrated substantial inconsistency.

That matters because without consistent information we cannot easily answer basic questions nationally.

Where are incidents occurring?

What type?

Are particular risks increasing?

Are drivers being assaulted?

Which safety interventions work?

Are there recurring patterns across operators or authorities?

My branch subsequently advanced a proposal for quarterly Local Transport Authority publication of bus-safety performance information, backed by annual independent assessment of the integrity of that data.

Again, this is not about collecting numbers for the sake of collecting numbers.

It is about creating a learning system.

Measure. Validate. Publish. Learn. Improve.

That same philosophy is behind my recent work on BODS.

Independent investigation also matters​


At the 2025 Bus Workers Conference, my branch also proposed the creation of a National Bus Crash Investigation Branch or equivalent independent investigation function.

The principle behind that proposal is important.

When a serious rail, aviation or maritime incident occurs, independent investigators can examine systemic causes and make recommendations designed to prevent recurrence.

A bus incident may involve police, DVSA, an operator, insurers, Traffic Commissioners, a highway authority and eventually a coroner.

Each has a legitimate role.

But those roles are not necessarily the same as an independent system-level safety investigation.

Such an investigation could examine:

  • fatigue;
  • timetable design;
  • vehicle design;
  • training;
  • management systems;
  • road infrastructure;
  • organisational culture;
  • contract incentives;
  • previous near misses;
  • and whether earlier warnings were missed.

The purpose would not be to excuse individual wrongdoing.

It would be to make sure we do not stop learning at the first convenient explanation.

Violence and abuse belong in the picture too​


During 2026 I have also campaigned on violence and abuse against bus drivers.

Bus drivers are lone frontline workers.

They deal with fare disputes, antisocial behaviour, intoxication, mental-health crises and conflict involving members of the public while simultaneously remaining responsible for the safe operation of a large passenger vehicle.

Again, this should not simply be classified as somebody else's problem.

Violence and abuse can affect concentration, stress, absence, retention and confidence.

It requires coordinated action from operators, police, Police and Crime Commissioners, Local Transport Authorities and Combined Authorities.

And once again, good data matter.

If incidents are recorded differently in every organisation—or buried individually in personnel files—we cannot properly understand the scale or pattern of the problem.

Local Transport Authorities now matter more than ever​


The role of Local and Combined Authorities in bus services is changing significantly.

Enhanced Partnerships and franchising mean that public bodies increasingly influence:

  • networks;
  • timetables;
  • performance standards;
  • contracts;
  • infrastructure;
  • fares;
  • passenger information; and
  • operational expectations.

That creates a major opportunity.

But greater control should bring greater responsibility.

My work on bus-safety governance has repeatedly asked whether the safety architecture is developing as quickly as the commercial and performance architecture.

Do authorities have meaningful safety KPIs?

Do they receive standardised incident data?

Is it independently checked?

Who within the authority has responsibility and competence for safety?

How does the workforce raise concerns directly?

Are safety requirements written into contracts?

Is safety discussed at the same senior level as punctuality, patronage and revenue?

These are reasonable questions.

And they become more important as public authorities gain greater control over services.

Talk to the people doing the job​


This brings me back to the video Tom Kearney sent me.

Toward the end of the clip, Liebreich's message is essentially this:

If decision-makers genuinely want to understand what is going wrong, talk to the drivers.

That should not be controversial.

Bus drivers are an enormous source of operational intelligence.

Every day they see:

  • the junction that repeatedly loses ten minutes;
  • the stop that creates unsafe movements;
  • the timing point where buses cannot safely wait;
  • the timetable that only works during school holidays;
  • the toilet that is permanently locked;
  • the recurring antisocial-behaviour hotspot;
  • the cab cooling system that repeatedly fails;
  • the roadworks nobody seems to have coordinated;
  • the point where passengers with mobility needs struggle to board;
  • the controller instruction that does not work in practice;
  • and the near miss which never becomes a formal statistic.

That knowledge should be part of the governance system.

Recognised workforce representatives should have a structured voice within Enhanced Partnerships, franchising arrangements, safety forums and relevant Local Transport Authority governance.

Not because unions should run the bus network.

But because policymaking is weaker when it excludes the people with daily operational experience of the system being regulated.

I have now put this point directly to the Senior Traffic Commissioner​


Following my main consultation submission, I have now sent a short supplementary evidence note to the Senior Traffic Commissioner drawing attention to this systems-safety principle.

I have not asked for my original response to be reopened or replaced.

I simply wanted the point formally on the record while the consultation is still live.

My submission argues that:

where a safety or performance problem repeatedly occurs, regulation should examine the system surrounding the driver as well as the final actions of the driver.

That principle is relevant to several of the consultation's questions.

It is relevant to:

  • realistic timetables;
  • punctuality improvement plans;
  • Local Transport Authority good practice;
  • reasonable excuse;
  • driver welfare;
  • heat;
  • network management;
  • evidence;
  • and the increasing use of BODS to analyse service performance.

Data can tell us where and when something repeatedly goes wrong.

Drivers can often help explain why.

We need both.

The consultation is still open — and drivers should take part​


The Senior Traffic Commissioner's consultation on Local Bus Service Performance Standards remains open until 11 December 2026.

It is reviewing guidance which has not undergone a significant wider review for more than ten years.

The subjects include:

  • the 95% punctuality standard;
  • improvement plans;
  • frequent services;
  • extreme heat;
  • realistic journey-specific timetables;
  • timing points;
  • Local Transport Authority traffic management;
  • examples of good and poor authority practice;
  • BODS enforcement;
  • financial penalties;
  • data-led monitoring; and
  • franchising enforcement.

You do not have to answer every question.

That means a driver with strong experience of unrealistic running times can respond on that.

A union representative with evidence about fatigue can respond on that.

An operator can explain genuine operational constraints.

A passenger can explain the impact of unreliable services.

An accessibility organisation can contribute evidence about information and digital exclusion.

A Local Transport Authority can explain network-management challenges.

This is how consultation should work.

Different people putting evidence into the same process.

The official consultation is available on GOV.UK under “Local bus service performance standards: consultation.”

The deadline is 11 December 2026.

I would encourage anyone with relevant experience to read it and make their own submission.

We need to stop treating working conditions as separate from safety​


None of this means that drivers should be absolved from individual responsibility.

We hold professional licences.

We have legal responsibilities.

Passengers rightly expect high standards.

Where a driver acts dangerously or unlawfully, that must be addressed.

But individual accountability and systems accountability are not alternatives.

A serious safety culture requires both.

The aviation industry does not improve safety by pretending pilots operate independently of fatigue, rostering, maintenance, training, air-traffic control and organisational systems.

Rail safety does not begin and end with the person driving the train.

The bus industry should not be different simply because our vehicles share ordinary roads.

A professional bus driver is part of a complex transport system.

If we genuinely want safer buses, more reliable services and fewer serious incidents, we have to examine that whole system.

That means looking at:

the timetable.

the duty.

the breaks.

the vehicle.

the cab environment.

the road.

the management system.

the reporting culture.

the contract.

the data.

the regulator.


And yes:

the driver.

But not only the driver.

That is why the National Bus Drivers' Bill of Rights still matters.

That is why the heat-safety campaign matters.

That is why better safety data matter.

That is why independent reporting matters.

That is why independent investigation matters.

That is why workforce representation matters.

And that is why this current review of national bus-performance guidance is an opportunity we should not waste.

Bus safety cannot stop at the driver.

We have to look at the system around them.



Further viewing​


Michael Liebreich speaking at the Bus Drivers' Bill of Rights rally, 5 November 2026:

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Consultation​


Senior Traffic Commissioner – Local bus service performance standards: consultation

Open until 11 December 2026.



This article represents my personal views as a serving bus driver and trade union representative. It discusses national transport policy and publicly available evidence. It does not represent the views of my employer, does not make allegations concerning the safety performance of any individual operator, and contains no confidential employer information.



Source: https://leeodams.blogspot.com/2026/11/bus-safety-cannot-stop-at-driver-we.html
Auto-imported from Lee Odam's blog.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Advertisement
Back
Top