From Deregulation to Public Control: Britain’s Bus Industry Is Being Redrawn at Speed

Live from London Bus Forums News

Live London Bus Forums News

Checking for live updates…

The latest live story will appear here when available.

Status
Not open for further replies.

​

National Express is preparing to transfer its dominant West Midlands local bus operation to the public authority. FirstGroup is selling buses and depots while repositioning itself for an asset-light franchised future. Combined Authorities are buying strategic infrastructure. Wales is heading towards nationwide franchising. Other regions are following.​

This is no longer a theoretical debate about what the British bus industry might look like one day. It is happening now — and remarkably quickly.​


I write this in a personal capacity as a serving bus driver and trade union representative. The views expressed here are my own. This article is based upon publicly available information and does not disclose confidential information belonging to my employer or any individual operator.


Something fundamental is happening​


For nearly forty years, most local bus services outside London have operated around a broadly familiar model.

A private operator owns or leases its buses and depot. It employs the workforce, registers commercial services, determines much of its own network, takes the fare revenue and carries much of the commercial risk.

Local authorities fund some socially necessary services, provide infrastructure and influence the network in various ways, but the basic operating model established after deregulation has remained recognisable.

That model is now being rewritten across large parts of Britain.

Not everywhere. Not overnight. And not in exactly the same way in every region.

But look at what is actually happening.

Greater Manchester has completed its transition to the Bee Network.

Liverpool City Region began operating its first franchised services in September 2026.

West Yorkshire's Weaver Network starts its first franchised services in 2027.

South Yorkshire has brought every major bus depot in the region into public ownership while preparing its publicly controlled network.

The West Midlands Combined Authority has agreed to acquire the dominant National Express local bus operation.

Cambridgeshire and Peterborough is progressing a phased franchising model.

The North East has completed and independently audited its franchising assessment and consultation, with a final decision still to be taken.

York and North Yorkshire began its statutory franchising assessment in October.

Wales intends franchising to be fully implemented across the country by the end of 2030.

Scotland has now announced its intention to legislate for greater public control and minimum expectations for bus services.

This is no longer a seminar about what might happen one day.

The structure of the bus industry is changing now.


The £260 million headline needs explaining​


FirstGroup's half-year results, published on 17 November 2026, provide one of the clearest indications yet of the scale of the transformation.

FirstGroup estimates that approximately £1.5 billion of annual regional bus revenue will become competitively franchised during the next five years in areas which have already formally announced that intention.

Within that figure, South Yorkshire, West Yorkshire and Wales — where First currently operates — represent approximately £260 million of FirstGroup's existing annual revenue.

That does not mean FirstGroup has suddenly been fined £260 million or is simply losing £260 million.

The significance is more profound.

Revenue currently generated through the traditional commercial bus model is moving into a market where public authorities increasingly determine the network and private companies compete for contracts to operate it.

FirstGroup openly says it will participate in those opportunities.

It expects franchising to produce lower operating margins but potentially stronger cash generation because the business can become more capital light.

Those two words — capital light — tell us a great deal about where at least part of the private bus industry believes its future lies.


National Express and the West Midlands: an extraordinary development​


The most dramatic example so far may be National Express in the West Midlands.

In August 2026, Mobico — National Express's parent company — announced an agreement in principle to sell the net assets and operations of its West Midlands bus business to the West Midlands Combined Authority.

WMCA says the operation accounts for approximately 94% of bus journeys in the West Midlands, involving around 4,800 employees, 1,300 buses and nine depots.

This isn't one depot changing hands.

It isn't the disposal of surplus vehicles.

It is the transfer of an enormous operating business.

The headline asset value is approximately £102 million. After around £78 million of transferred liabilities — including pension liabilities and electric-vehicle contracts — Mobico expects upfront residual proceeds of around £24 million.

But arguably the most revealing part is Mobico's explanation for doing it.

The company says the transaction substantially “de-risks” the group from uncertainty arising from forthcoming franchising.

That wording matters.

One of Britain's largest and most established local bus operations has reached the point where its parent company considers selling the incumbent operation to the public authority preferable to carrying that existing business through the coming structural change.

That deserves national attention.


Precision matters: National Express is not disappearing​


It is important not to overstate this.

National Express is not disappearing from Britain.

The coach business continues, and Mobico remains a major international transport group.

The transaction concerns the existing West Midlands local bus operation.

Nor should the transaction be described as completed until completion is formally confirmed.

But those qualifications do not make the underlying development ordinary.

The dominant operator in one of Britain's largest metropolitan bus markets is preparing to transfer its local operating business, workforce, fleet, depots and liabilities to the public authority during the transition towards franchising.

That would have sounded extraordinary only a few years ago.

Now it forms part of a much wider pattern.


FirstGroup is taking a different route​


FirstGroup's strategy is particularly interesting because it demonstrates that operators do not all have to respond to franchising in the same way.

First is not walking away.

It is selling substantial physical assets while actively competing for the new operating contracts.

Its latest results confirm completed depot sales in South Yorkshire and Wales and an agreement to sell five West Yorkshire depots and 330 buses for £109 million.

Following the transition in West Yorkshire, South Yorkshire and Wales, FirstGroup expects its owned regional bus fleet to fall from around 4,500 vehicles to approximately 2,900.

Yet First has already secured major West Yorkshire franchise contracts.

The Bramley and Huddersfield contracts are expected to generate around £40 million of annual revenue.

Under those arrangements, the West Yorkshire Combined Authority carries the revenue risk and specifies the service levels, while FirstGroup delivers the operation.

This could be a glimpse of the future bus company.

It may no longer need to own every depot.

It may no longer need to own every bus.

It may no longer determine the network.

It may not carry the farebox risk.

Instead, its expertise becomes operating the system somebody else controls.


Public control is not necessarily public operation​


This distinction is crucial.

Public control, public ownership, municipal operation and franchising are not interchangeable terms.

Under most franchising arrangements, private companies continue operating the buses.

The authority determines the network and awards contracts. It may set routes, timetables, fares, vehicle standards, branding and performance requirements.

The company winning the contract employs staff and delivers the service.

West Yorkshire provides a clear example.

The Combined Authority says it will control routes, fares and service standards under the Weaver Network, while private operators compete for the contracts. First and Transdev have already secured major first-round work.

So the emerging model is not necessarily old-fashioned nationalisation.

It can instead be:

publicly controlled system + competitively contracted private operation.

That is a very different market from traditional deregulation.


Look at the depots​


Depots are one of the clearest signs of how profound the change is.

A strategically located depot is not merely a building with a large yard.

It is operational infrastructure.

Hundreds of buses may depend upon it. Engineering, charging, fuelling, cleaning, control functions and thousands of employee movements can depend upon where those facilities are located.

Historically, depot ownership has given major incumbent operators considerable structural strength.

Increasingly, public authorities are separating that strategic infrastructure from the company operating the services.

South Yorkshire has brought all six major bus depots into public ownership. Five were acquired from private operators, joining an already publicly owned Doncaster depot. First and Stagecoach initially lease the facilities back while franchising is prepared. The wider programme includes electrification and new fleet investment, with the first franchised services planned for September 2027.

West Yorkshire is going in the same direction.

It is buying strategic depots and creating a Combined Authority-owned vehicle fleet. New Weaver Network buses will be leased to operators rather than permanently tied to whichever company happens to hold the contract at a particular moment.

That reduces one of the biggest barriers to entry in the bus market.

A company bidding to run a franchise may no longer need to arrive with hundreds of buses and a strategically located depot of its own.

That could increase competition.

But it also changes what being a bus operator actually means.


Liverpool is no longer talking about franchising in the future tense​


Liverpool City Region moved from policy into operation on 6 September 2026, when the first franchised services began in St Helens.

Stagecoach secured the St Helens operating contract, while Go-Ahead was selected for Wirral.

The whole network is intended to move to public control by the end of 2027.

Liverpool is also investing more than £150 million in over 560 new buses for the publicly controlled network.

Again, private companies remain involved.

But the relationship changes.

They operate the authority's network.

That distinction is fundamental.


South Yorkshire may be an even clearer example of the future structure​


South Yorkshire is worth watching particularly closely because the separation between strategic assets and operating contracts is so visible.

Every major depot is publicly owned.

Fleet procurement is progressing.

Depot electrification is underway.

Private operators are bidding to run the contracts.

Franchised services are expected to begin in September 2027.

The authority owns or controls an increasing part of the operating platform.

The private company competes for the right to run services on it.

This is not merely a different way of procuring a bus route.

It is a different allocation of power within the industry.


West Yorkshire begins in 2027​


West Yorkshire's Weaver Network is due to start operating franchised services in 2027, with the entire bus network intended to come under public control by the end of 2028.

First West Yorkshire and Transdev have already signed major contracts, with a much wider range of large and smaller operators participating in the procurement process.

That final point matters.

A publicly controlled system does not necessarily mean a smaller operator market.

If the authority owns strategic depots and vehicles and divides work into contracts of different sizes, smaller operators may actually find it easier to participate.

That could significantly change the competitive landscape.


Wales could be the most ambitious transformation of all​


Wales is moving towards something different again.

Transport for Wales says bus franchising remains on course to be fully implemented by the end of 2030.

The current sequencing is South West Wales in 2028, North Wales in 2029, and South East and Mid Wales in 2030, subject to the necessary secondary legislation.

Operators will bid to run services against publicly specified requirements covering matters including routes, timetables, fares, operating hours and service-quality standards.

That is significant because the ambition is national.

Rather than one city region reorganising its buses, an entire country's bus system is moving towards a planned franchised framework.


Scotland is also moving​


Scotland is moving in the same broad direction, although its eventual model is still developing.

Transport Scotland announced in November 2026 that legislation intended to bring the bus network back into greater public control and establish minimum service expectations would form the next stage of Scottish bus policy.

FirstGroup is paying attention too.

Its latest investor results specifically discuss the changing direction in Scotland alongside franchising developments elsewhere.

That matters because when major listed transport companies start discussing public-control policy in investor documents, we are no longer dealing with a marginal political debate.

It has become part of corporate strategy.


Other regions are moving too​


Cambridgeshire and Peterborough intends to introduce franchising through a phased approach beginning in 2027, specifically choosing to learn from other areas and reduce implementation risk.

The North East has completed its franchising assessment and independent audit. Its consultation has closed and the authority says a final mayoral decision will follow; no final decision had been taken at the consultation stage.

York and North Yorkshire formally began its statutory assessment process on 2 October 2026, allocating up to £3.5 million to establish whether franchising would produce better outcomes.

Put all of that together and the pattern becomes difficult to ignore.


The law has changed too​


The policy change has been accompanied by legal change.

Franchising powers are now available to all Local Transport Authorities in England. Government guidance explicitly says authorities can choose franchising where they consider it appropriate, while Enhanced Partnerships remain an alternative.

The Bus Services Act 2025 widened the toolkit further.

From 26 January 2026, provisions including those allowing new local authority bus companies came into force. Government guidance now makes clear that every local authority outside London can establish a new Local Authority Bus Company if it chooses.

That doesn't mean councils are all about to start bus companies.

It means the legal assumption has changed.

Authorities now have significantly more options available to them: franchising, strengthened Enhanced Partnerships, publicly owned strategic assets and, if they choose, their own operating companies.

The old model is no longer the only model available.


So what about the East Midlands?​


This is where the national developments become particularly relevant to Nottinghamshire and Derbyshire.

At present, EMCCA is not pursuing bus franchising.

That should be stated clearly.

There is no public evidence that EMCCA is preparing to acquire Trentbarton, Nottingham City Transport, Arriva or any other local bus operator.

There is no evidence of a West Midlands-style transaction being prepared here.

EMCCA's new Enhanced Partnership Plan says explicitly that it has chosen an Enhanced Partnership approach “rather than pursuing bus franchising at this time.”

But the final three words matter.

At this time.

The same document says the East Midlands needs to move beyond the limitations of a fully deregulated market and work in a more coordinated way.

That doesn't mean franchising is inevitable.

It does mean it would be unwise to treat today's structure as though it were guaranteed forever.


Public money is already becoming more deeply involved in East Midlands bus infrastructure​


There is another reason the East Midlands should watch national developments closely.

EMCCA is already considering and funding major strategic transport investments involving private and municipal operators.

Its October 2026 Investment Committee papers included Arriva depot electrification, Mansfield depot electrification, NCT bus and depot electrification, Trentbarton depot electrification, and wider bus-corridor infrastructure and customer-experience schemes.

That doesn't transfer ownership.

But it does demonstrate how the boundary between private operator infrastructure and publicly supported regional transport infrastructure is changing.

As more public money goes into depots, charging systems, vehicles and corridors, reasonable questions follow.

What public-value conditions attach to that investment?

What happens to publicly funded infrastructure if ownership changes?

What happens if the authority later changes its operating model?

What guarantees exist for continuity?

And what protections follow the public investment?

Those questions should be considered before, not after, structural change.


The biggest mistake would be to think this is only about who owns the buses​


Ownership matters.

But it is not the only issue, and perhaps not even the most important issue.

The deeper question is:

Who controls the system?

If the authority determines the network, specifies the timetable, controls fares, carries revenue risk, owns the depot, owns or funds the vehicle, monitors performance and awards the operating contract, then significant power has moved from the operator to the public body.

And whenever power moves, accountability should move with it.

That has profound implications for passengers.

It also has profound implications for the workforce and for safety.


Public control must mean public safety accountability​


Franchising does not remove the legal responsibilities of the operator.

The operating company remains responsible for its operator licence.

It remains an employer with health and safety duties.

Drivers continue to carry individual professional and legal responsibilities.

None of that disappears.

But once a public authority increasingly controls routes, running times, service specifications, performance regimes, depots, vehicles and operational data, it becomes increasingly difficult to pretend that system-level safety belongs entirely to the operator.

If an authority specifies a timetable, it should care whether the timetable is realistically achievable.

If it imposes punctuality requirements, it should understand whether the performance system creates unintended pressure.

If it owns the depot, driver welfare facilities become relevant.

If it owns the buses, driver cab conditions should matter every bit as much as passenger comfort.

If it holds AVL and BODS data showing that the same journeys repeatedly lose time in the same places, it has evidence capable of informing safer service design.

If it lets contracts worth millions of pounds, safety should be part of contract governance.

And if a serious incident occurs, the authority should be interested not merely in whether somebody can be blamed, but in what the system can learn.

Greater public control must mean greater public accountability.


Public control should also mean public safety transparency​


There is another issue which becomes more important as public authorities take greater control of bus networks:

the collection and publication of bus-safety data.

For years, one weakness of bus-safety governance outside London has been fragmentation.

Different organisations can collect different information using different definitions.

Collision information may sit with an operator.

Road casualty information may sit with police or highway authorities.

Workplace injury information may sit elsewhere.

Passenger falls and non-collision injuries may be recorded differently again.

Driver assaults may enter operator HR or security systems without necessarily forming part of the wider picture of network safety.

Near misses may never become public data at all.

That makes it difficult to see the whole system.

And public control creates an opportunity to change that.


If authorities can measure punctuality, they can measure safety​


This is where I think the debate needs to become much more demanding.

We already increasingly measure bus performance in extraordinary detail.

AVL systems can show where buses are.

BODS can carry timetable, location and fare information.

Authorities can analyse punctuality, cancellations, journey times, patronage, congestion and reliability.

The Department for Transport has itself disclosed work looking at greater use of BODS for data-led punctuality monitoring, targeting, remote intervention, evidence packs and referrals for enforcement.

Performance regulation is becoming increasingly data-driven.

That is potentially a good thing.

But there is a glaring question:

Are we building a more sophisticated national system for measuring whether a bus is five minutes late than for understanding whether people are being injured on the network?

That would be the wrong priority.

The answer is not to collect less performance data.

It is to raise safety information to the same level of seriousness.


A publicly controlled network should know what is happening on it​


If a Combined Authority is responsible for specifying and monitoring a major bus network, it should be capable of understanding its safety performance.

That should include meaningful information about collisions, passenger casualties, pedestrians, cyclists and other vulnerable road users, driver and employee injuries, serious and fatal incidents, passenger falls, assaults and violence, recurring safety-critical locations, vehicle-related concerns and significant trends over time.

That information should not simply be accumulated.

It should be analysed.

Patterns should be identified.

And where information can properly be published without compromising individual privacy, legal proceedings or legitimate confidentiality, meaningful anonymised information should routinely be placed in the public domain.

We already expect public authorities to tell us whether buses are punctual.

We expect passenger numbers.

We expect information about service reliability.

We expect financial information and customer-performance information.

Why should safety be treated as though it belongs in a separate locked box?

Safety is part of service performance.


We need common definitions​


Franchising also creates a practical opportunity to solve another long-standing problem.

When several different companies operate contracts within one publicly controlled network, the authority can specify a common reporting system.

A collision should mean the same thing whichever company operates the bus.

A serious passenger injury should be classified consistently.

An assault on a member of staff should not effectively disappear from comparisons because one operator records it differently from another.

Passenger falls should have consistent definitions.

Near misses should be capable of being analysed consistently.

The same applies to vehicle defects and other safety-critical occurrences.

That common taxonomy could be written into contracts.

Then authorities could genuinely compare trends across operators and across time.

More importantly, if common standards were developed nationally, we could begin comparing networks across Britain.


Franchising should create a national safety-data opportunity​


Britain now faces a choice.

We can allow every franchising authority to invent its own safety-data system.

If that happens, we risk recreating fragmentation inside the new public-control model.

Or central government, Traffic Commissioners, DVSA, Combined Authorities, Local Transport Authorities, operators and the workforce could develop a national minimum bus-safety reporting standard.

Authorities could still collect additional information locally.

But the core dataset should be consistent.

That could provide something the bus industry has historically struggled to achieve:

a reliable national picture of safety performance capable of being compared over time and between places.

That would improve transparency.

It would support better research.

It would allow emerging risks to be recognised sooner.

It would provide elected politicians with evidence rather than anecdotes.

And it would make it more difficult for systemic problems to disappear between organisational boundaries.


Publication matters as much as collection​


There is little public-accountability value in creating sophisticated internal dashboards that nobody outside the organisation can ever scrutinise.

Publication should obviously be proportionate.

Personal information must be protected.

Ongoing police investigations cannot be compromised.

Genuine security or commercial concerns may sometimes require redaction.

But none of those issues justify treating meaningful aggregate safety information as inherently secret.

A mature publicly controlled transport system should be comfortable saying:

This is how many incidents occurred.

This is the trend.

This is what categories they fall into.

This is where recurring risks have been identified.

And this is what we are doing about them.

That is not reputational damage.

That is accountability.


Serious incidents should create system-wide learning​


The same principle applies after something goes badly wrong.

A serious collision should not become information which exists only inside the operator directly involved.

The question should not simply be whether the driver committed an offence, whether the vehicle had a defect or whether an insurance claim is settled.

Those questions may all matter.

But a learning system asks more.

Was fatigue involved?

Was the timetable realistic?

Was there recurring timetable pressure?

Had a dangerous road layout been identified before?

Had previous near misses happened?

Had drivers already raised concerns?

Was there a vehicle-design issue?

Did training contribute?

Did communication systems contribute?

Was there an organisational problem?

Were contractual incentives relevant?

And, crucially, could the same problem exist elsewhere?

Where lessons are identified, they should be capable of being shared across operators.

An authority controlling an entire network is ideally placed to make sure learning does not stop at the boundary of one contracted company.

Where possible, anonymised learning should also be made public.

A public transport system should not simply count incidents.

It should learn from them.


Safety information should include the workforce​


There is another risk in designing safety-data systems entirely from boardrooms.

Drivers, engineers, controllers and other frontline staff see things before management dashboards see them.

They know the junction where there are repeated near misses.

They know the stop which creates poor sight lines.

They know the route where an unrealistic timetable repeatedly removes recovery time.

They know where passengers regularly fall.

They know where assaults happen.

They know which welfare facility is permanently unavailable.

And they know which vehicle problems recur.

That information has value.

Publicly controlled networks should therefore have clear, protected routes through which frontline employees and recognised trade unions can raise systemic concerns.

A serious safety-governance system needs both quantitative evidence and workforce intelligence.

One without the other is incomplete.


This is why transparency cannot be separated from franchising​


The franchising debate is often dominated by fares, routes and branding.

Understandably so.

Passengers want affordable fares.

They want reliable services.

They want simple tickets.

They want buses where and when they need them.

But if public authorities are taking responsibility for the system, then safety governance should be built into that system from the beginning.

Not bolted on afterwards.

Contracts should require meaningful incident reporting.

Authorities should publish safety indicators.

Workforce reporting routes should be clear.

Serious incidents should create shared learning.

And safety information should sit alongside reliability, punctuality and patronage in the routine public performance picture.

Public control without public safety transparency would be an enormous missed opportunity.


Then there is the workforce​


The structural transformation also raises huge questions for bus workers.

A driver may continue driving broadly the same route from broadly the same depot while the company employing them changes because somebody else wins the next contract.

Government franchising guidance expressly recognises this.

It provides for TUPE to apply in relevant transfers and requires consultation over which employees are principally connected with affected services. It also provides pension protection so that qualifying transferring employees receive pension rights which are the same as or broadly comparable with their previous arrangements.

Those protections matter.

But they should be treated as a floor rather than the whole workforce policy.


What happens after the first transfer?​


The harder questions begin once franchising becomes established.

What happens to longstanding local collective agreements when contracts are re-tendered?

What happens to trade-union recognition?

What happens to depot-specific agreements?

What happens to established rosters?

What happens to pay structures?

What happens to facilities?

What happens to continuity of service when work is reorganised between packages?

What happens if one operator loses a contract to several competitors?

And how do we prevent repeated contracting cycles from slowly eroding conditions?

These are not arguments against franchising.

They are arguments for designing it properly.


Public procurement must not create a race to the bottom​


If public authorities control contracts worth hundreds of millions of pounds, they have enormous purchasing power.

That power should not be used to create a bidding war over who can provide labour most cheaply.

The public sector should not spend public money creating poorer jobs.

Employment standards should be embedded into franchising.

Continuity of service matters.

Pensions matter.

Trade-union recognition matters.

Collective bargaining matters.

Pay protection matters.

Safe scheduling matters.

Fatigue management matters.

Welfare facilities matter.

And proper workforce consultation matters.

A publicly controlled bus network should demonstrate that better public transport and decent employment standards reinforce each other.


The future operator market could look completely different​


There is another consequence worth thinking about.

Traditional bus companies have often been geographically rooted businesses.

They owned local depots.

They built fleets over decades.

They developed their own commercial networks.

Their identities became intertwined with particular regions.

Under a more asset-light franchising model, operating companies may become increasingly mobile contractors.

Company A may run a package for five years.

Company B may win it next time.

Company C may take it later.

The buses might remain in the same public livery.

The depot might remain publicly owned.

The routes might remain essentially unchanged.

Passengers might hardly notice who the legal operator is.

But the driver's employer could change.

That changes the balance between brand continuity for the passenger and employment continuity for the workforce.

It needs thinking through now.


What will a “bus company” actually be?​


This may ultimately be one of the biggest questions.

If a company does not necessarily own the bus, does not necessarily own the depot, does not set the routes, does not control the fares, may not carry the passenger-revenue risk and operates against an authority-defined timetable and performance regime, what exactly has the bus company become?

Increasingly, it may be:

a contracted provider of operational management, labour and expertise within somebody else's transport system.

That is not inherently good or bad.

But it is fundamentally different from the traditional deregulated model.

And major operators have clearly recognised it.

FirstGroup's explicit description of a more capital-light franchise model is important precisely because it shows that corporate strategy is adapting to the new landscape.


None of this means franchising automatically succeeds​


It is important to avoid presenting franchising as a magic wand.

Public authorities can make bad decisions too.

A badly designed timetable remains a badly designed timetable whether it was written by a private company or a Combined Authority.

Revenue forecasts can be wrong.

Costs can rise.

Contracts can be badly structured.

Procurement can fail.

Political priorities can change.

Public budgets can come under pressure.

The test should therefore never simply be:

“Is this publicly controlled?”

The tests should be whether it provides a better, safer, more reliable, more accessible and more accountable service; whether it represents good value; and whether it provides decent conditions for the people delivering it.

Public control creates possibilities.

It does not automatically guarantee outcomes.


But pretending nothing fundamental is changing would be equally mistaken​


Look at the cumulative picture again.

Greater Manchester controls the Bee Network.

Liverpool has begun operating franchised services.

South Yorkshire owns all its major depots.

West Yorkshire is acquiring buses and strategic infrastructure.

National Express is preparing to transfer its dominant West Midlands local operation to WMCA.

FirstGroup is selling substantial physical assets while actively pursuing operating contracts.

Wales is building towards nationwide franchising.

Scotland is preparing further public-control legislation.

Cambridgeshire and Peterborough is progressing franchising.

The North East has completed its assessment and consultation.

York and North Yorkshire has begun its assessment.

And English local authorities can once again establish their own bus companies.

That is not a small policy adjustment.

It is a restructuring of the bus industry.


The East Midlands should learn before it has to react​


EMCCA may ultimately decide that an Enhanced Partnership remains the right model for Nottinghamshire and Derbyshire.

That is a legitimate choice.

But it would be unwise for operators, unions or policymakers here to ignore what is happening elsewhere simply because franchising is not currently being pursued.

The national market is changing.

Legal powers have changed.

Operator strategies are changing.

Public ownership of strategic infrastructure is becoming normal in some regions.

Procurement models are changing.

And the relationship between operator and authority is changing.

So the East Midlands should be asking these questions now.

What workforce protections would we require if the model ever changed?

What happens to public investment in strategic assets?

What safety standards should accompany public funding?

How should safety information be reported?

What role should recognised unions have in governance?

What happens to pensions, continuity and collective agreements?

What would good franchising look like if it were ever considered here?

Thinking about those questions does not commit anyone to franchising.

It means not being caught unprepared.


The argument has moved on​


A few years ago, much of the political argument was:

Should buses be franchised?

That question still matters in places deciding their future model.

But nationally the debate is already moving beyond it.

In many areas, the more important questions are becoming:

How should franchising work?

Who should own the assets?

Who should carry the revenue risk?

How should operators compete?

How should workers be protected?

How should safety be governed?

What information should be published?

And how should public authorities be held accountable for the decisions they increasingly control?

Those questions are much harder.

They are also much more important.


If we are rebuilding the industry, build something better​


This transformation provides an opportunity that should not be wasted.

If Britain is going to redesign a bus-industry structure created almost forty years ago, why reproduce its weaknesses inside a new contracting system?

This is the opportunity to build in stronger workforce protections.

It is the opportunity to address fatigue and unrealistic running times.

It is the opportunity to put welfare facilities into contracts.

It is the opportunity to strengthen protection against violence and abuse.

It is the opportunity to build proper heat-safety standards into vehicle specifications.

It is the opportunity to create confidential safety-reporting arrangements.

It is the opportunity to establish common safety-data definitions.

It is the opportunity to publish meaningful safety information routinely.

It is the opportunity to share learning from serious incidents across whole networks.

And it is the opportunity to give professional drivers and recognised workforce representatives a structured voice within transport governance.

Otherwise we risk creating a new commercial model around some very old problems.


Public control brings public responsibility​


For me, everything comes back to one principle.

The more control a public authority exercises over a bus network, the harder it becomes to avoid responsibility for the consequences of the decisions it controls.

If it controls the timetable, running time matters.

If it controls performance standards, fatigue and operational pressure matter.

If it owns the depot, welfare matters.

If it owns the bus, cab safety matters.

If it controls procurement, employment standards matter.

If it controls the network, workforce involvement matters.

If it collects the data, transparency matters.

And if serious incidents occur within the system it has designed, learning matters.

That does not replace the responsibilities of operators.

It does not remove individual driver responsibility.

It means responsibility must exist at every level of the system.


The bus industry of 2030 could look very different​


By the end of this decade, large parts of Britain could have publicly planned networks, publicly controlled strategic depots, publicly owned fleets and private companies competing mainly to operate contracts.

Other regions may continue with strengthened Enhanced Partnerships.

Some authorities may create their own municipal companies.

Wales intends nationwide franchising.

Scotland intends greater public control.

Different operators will choose different strategies: some may retain assets, some may sell assets and become contract operators, some may enter new regions and some may decide certain markets are no longer attractive.

Nobody can confidently predict every result.

But the direction of travel is visible.


And it is happening at speed​


That is perhaps the most remarkable part of all this.

It isn't simply the amount of change.

It is the speed.

Greater Manchester was once treated as the great experiment.

Now Liverpool has commenced franchising.

West Yorkshire has signed contracts.

South Yorkshire has bought its depots.

National Express is preparing to transfer its West Midlands local operation.

FirstGroup is openly restructuring for a more capital-light franchised future.

Wales is working towards a national franchised system.

Other regions are progressing assessments or implementation.

And Parliament has broadened the powers available to public authorities.

Events are moving faster than much of the debate surrounding them.


The real question now​


The argument is no longer simply whether Britain's bus industry will change.

It already is.

The real questions are who shapes that change, who benefits from it, who carries the financial risk, who owns the strategic infrastructure, who employs and protects the workforce, who controls the safety system, who owns and publishes the evidence, and who is accountable when something goes wrong.

Those decisions will shape British buses for decades.

Drivers, engineers, passengers, trade unions, operators, public authorities, elected representatives and regulators all have an interest in getting them right.

Because once the structures, contracts and assets are fixed, changing them later becomes far more difficult.

The great restructuring of Britain's bus industry has begun.

The question now is whether we simply allow it to happen around us —

or whether we use this once-in-a-generation change to build a safer, fairer, more transparent and genuinely accountable bus system.



This article represents my personal views as a serving bus driver and trade union representative. It is based upon publicly available government, transport-authority, operator and investor information. It does not represent the views of my employer, does not predict or allege any future ownership change involving an individual East Midlands operator, and contains no confidential employer information.



Source: https://leeodams.blogspot.com/2026/11/from-deregulation-to-public-control.html
Auto-imported from Lee Odam's blog.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Advertisement
Back
Top